urgent reply po sana
1 urgent reply po sana on Sat Jan 12, 2013 10:14 pm
2 Re: urgent reply po sana on Sat Jan 12, 2013 11:04 pm
melvin madrilejos wrote:gusto ko lang malaman kung pwede bang magfile ang asawa ng bigamy kung alam po niya ang relasyon ng 2 sa simula pa lamang.
(i-clear muna natin to)
maari po ba at ano ang mangyayari kapag nauna magfile ng annulment ang inaakusahan ng bigamy?alin ang didinggin ng court ang naunang annulment case na ififile o bigamy?thank you and more power
Lets dissect your problem.
Bigamy is the proper case when there is a subsequent marriage, without annulling or nullfying the previous marriage. IT means that there are 2(two)celebrated marriages.
In the case presented, there is ONLY "relasyon" from the start. Relationship is different from Marriage, pwedeng may relasyon sila pero hinde sila kasal.
Or maybe whats on your mind is a case for adultery or concubinage.
3 Re: urgent reply po sana on Sun Jan 13, 2013 11:46 am
5 Re: urgent reply po sana on Sun Jan 13, 2013 12:04 pm
6 Re: urgent reply po sana on Mon Jan 14, 2013 9:45 am
There is no case for the 1st wife, although, may alleged na "kasulatan". Yung kasulatan kasi is VOID yun being against public policy. Di mo yun magagamit bilang evidence laban sa 1st wife. Kahit batid nya pa lahat. kasi, bigamy is a crime against the state.
If na file na ang bigamy case then na ARRAIGNed na yung lalaki and yung 2nd wife, the case will continue kahit wala dito sa pinas ang lalaki.
If mamatay ang 1st wife, the case will be dismissed because the 1st wife will serve as the witness in the case. So wala ng witness.
If mamatay ang lalaki or yung 2nd wife, still the case will be dismissed kasi nga, sabi ng Revised Penal COde, Death extinguishes criminal liability.
Now, in your 1st question, that is the typical text-book example of Prejudicial question, alin ba ang mauuna, yung bigamy case or yung annulment case, my answer is yung bigamy case ang mauuna i resolve ng court, pending muna yung annulment case, because the decision or resolution in the bigamy case is determinative to the guilt or innocence of the accused(lalaki). So if the court finds out that innocent yung lalaki sa bigamy case then idismiss yung bigamy case then i dismiss rin yung annulment case.
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum