Free Legal Advice Philippines

Disclaimer: This web site is designed for general information only and does not create attorney-client relationship. Persons accessing this site are encouraged to seek independent counsel for legal advice regarding their individual legal issues.

Log in

I forgot my password




You are not connected. Please login or register

Swendling for not finishing a system project for student

View previous topic View next topic Go down  Message [Page 1 of 1]

whoozaa


Arresto Menor
Ako po ay programmer, meron po na student na lumapit sakin para magpagawa ng system, ito po ay thesis nila, at nagkasundo po kami sa price at kung saan lang yung system na gagawin ko na naka depende sa instruction nila at ito po ay walang kasulatan, verbal lang kami nagkasundo, natapos ko po ito at nakuha ko na ng buo ang bayad, pero kada pa check nila ng system padagdag ng padagdag yung adviser nila at sabi ko sa kanila dagdag kabayaran na rin yung update kasi wala sa usapan namin yun, 4 times sila nagpa update sa system at yung last hindi na nila kinumpleto ang bayad para sa update, ngayon nag defend na sila ng thesis at may revision, magpapagawa sila ulit ng revision sakin pero tinanggihan ko ito kasi nawala tiwala ko sa kanila dahil yung last di kompleto ang kabayaran ng update, kaya sabi ko kung magbabayad din naman kayo sa ibang programmer nalang.

Ngayon po gusto nila mag file ng kaso sakin ng swendling dahil hindi ko raw kinumpleto yung system nila, sabi ko naman hindi ko na obligasyon yung revision kasi dapat pinag aralan nila yun ginawa ko at sila na dapat gumawa.

Tanong ko lang po kung may chance na makasuhan ako ng swendling kung mapatunayan at ano rin po ang i file ko against sa kanila kasi nagtatrabaho po ako sa ibang lugar ngayon at madidisturbo ako o mawalan ng trabaho kung sakali i summon ako sa court?

View user profile

whoozaa


Arresto Menor
Yung time po pala na ginawa ko yung last update ay nandito na po ako sa manila kasi may employer na nag hire sakin at sila po ay nasa probinsya, ngayon pinapa barangay nila ako at sabi ko naman kay misis wag ibigay ang contact details ko kasi hindi pwede ako umuwi ng province at malayo saka baka matanggal ako sa trabaho, sa ngayon ang nirereklamo nila sa barangay ay si misis kasi yung last na kabayaran sa update sabi ko ibigay nalang kay misis, wala si misis alam sa usapan tungkol sa thesis na pinagawa at alam niya lang na bayad nila ito saakin, ngayon pati si misis nirereklamo sa barangay kasi kasabwat daw, at bago napunta sa barangay inassault muna nila si misis sa bahay at walang naisagot si misis sa kanila kasi nga wala siyang alam.

Ano po ba yung pwede nilang i file na kaso kay misis at ano rin po ang pweding ibalik ni misis sa kanila na kaso, nag search din po ako, baka pwede po libel or slander, tama po ba?

View user profile

whoozaa


Arresto Menor
Sir/Mam pls i need an advise, google advice is not enough...

View user profile

centro


Reclusion Perpetua
I will restate your situation to better understand what transpired based on the narration stated. I will write in English because I am picking up provisions in English and shorter to write.
• A programming student commissioned you for a project.
• There was an agreement on the price and the output. There was no written agreement.
• It is not clear what exactly are the deliverables.
• It appears there were revisions, how many it was not stated. From your view, it was not covered in the agreement.
• Yet revisions were demanded. It was not clear how much was charged for the revisions relative to the original agreement.
• At this point, the possible violation is breach of contract if the deliverables were clear and not delivered, if payments were agreed upon and were not made, if standards were set and not met.
• If it is swindling, here is how 315-319 of the revised penal code words it. Check if your situation meets the definition (only some selections):
1. With unfaithfulness or abuse of confidence, namely:
(a) By altering the substance, quantity, or quality or anything of value which the offender shall deliver by virtue of an obligation to do so, even though such obligation be based on an immoral or illegal consideration.
2. By means of any of the following false pretenses or fraudulent acts executed prior to or simultaneously with the commission of the fraud: (b) By altering the quality, fineness or weight of anything pertaining to his art or business
Under Article 316 5. Any person who shall accept any compensation given him under the belief that it was in payment of services rendered or labor performed by him, when in fact he did not actually perform such services or labor.

It appears you agreed to do the revision. But still not clear up to what extent.
The student filed charges at the barangay. Although it was not stated what the charges were I assumed they pertained to for non deliverables.

Your wife was subjected to humiliation. Review Art 287 of the Revised Penal Code “There is a provision to include any human conduct that, although not productive of some physical or material harm, could unjustifiably annoy or vex an innocent person. The paramount question to be considered is whether the offender’s act caused annoyance, irritation, torment, distress, or disturbance to the mind of the person to whom it was directed.”

Patuloy mo lang ang pagreresearch ng possible violations ayon sa Penal Code para malaman initially kung sino ang tama. Mahalaga na klaro ang mga unang usapin:
1. Ano ang original agreement? Hanggang saan ang deliverables sa programang ginawa mo? Kanino ang ownership?
2. Noong pumawag ka sa revisions, ano ang bagong agreement?
3. Paaano nanaman nabali?
4. Ano ang charges sa Barangay?

Magtanongtanong din sa iba. Perspektiba ko lang ito ayon sa pagkakaintindi ko. Paki validate at icorrect kung may di tamang intindi.

View user profile

whoozaa


Arresto Menor
They suing me of swindling for not doing the revisions and it is not my concern anymore because its not part of the original agreement and it is already 100% done, yung revisions ay panibagong agreement naman po yun, saka ayaw ko na rin po tanggapin kasi yung last payment nila saakin para sa update ay kulang at kay misis ko ipinaabot yung bayad nila at binaniwala ko na po kasi busy na rin ako sa bagong trabaho ko at sinabi ko na sa iba nalang sila magpagawa ng revisions kasi wala na akong tiwala sa kanila.

I guess di yata ako papasok dito -

"Any person who shall accept any compensation given him under the belief that it was in payment of services rendered or labor performed by him, when in fact he did not actually perform such services or labor."

Kasi lahat naman nagawa ko at 100% pwera lang sa pinapagawa nilang revisions.

At bago po nila pinatawag sa barangay si misis nakiusap sila na gawin ko daw yung revisions, sabi ko naman walang problema sa akin basta bayaran yung kulang at mag hingi ng pasensya sila kay misis dahil sa pag sisigaw nila sa labas ng bahay pati yung 4yrs old kong anak natakot sa kanila.

Yung reply nila sa text kaya nilang bayaran pero di nila kayang humingi ng pasensya or mag sorry kay misis kaya di ko na tinanggap yung revisions.

View user profile

Sponsored content


View previous topic View next topic Back to top  Message [Page 1 of 1]

Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum