Free Legal Advice Philippines

Disclaimer: This web site is designed for general information only and does not create attorney-client relationship. Persons accessing this site are encouraged to seek independent counsel for legal advice regarding their individual legal issues.

Log in

I forgot my password




You are not connected. Please login or register

slight physical injury against a minor's self defense

View previous topic View next topic Go down  Message [Page 1 of 1]

kln


Arresto Menor
Need advice lang po, regarding my brother who is 17 yrs old na nakipag-away sa isang 32 yr.old na lalaki pero ung 32 yr.old guy po ung nanguna at dumepensa lng po ung kapatid ko..
Ang nangyari po kasi ay nakahiga ung kapatid ko at natutulog at naghihintay po dun sa pagupitan dahil magpapagupit po ng buhok ng lumapit ung 32 yr old at ginigising ng suntok ung kapatid ko. Eh nilalagnat pa nga po ung kapatid ko nun at ginising pa po sa suntok nung 32 yr.old na lalaki hangang sa nagaway na at dinikdik ung kapatid ko sa pader at nung umuwi po sa bahay nila ung lalaki kumuha ng pamalo na sulo at pinagpapalo ung kapatid ko. Sinasangga nmn po ng kapatid ko ng kamay nya hanggang sa pinukol po ung kapatid ko nung sulo at nung nahawakan ng kapatid ko ung sulo,pinalo po nya dun sa lalaki so ung lalaki nagtamo po ng sugat sa ulo.
Tapos pinahuli po sa pulis ung kapatid ko at nung nagpunta po samin ung pulis, ang sabi lng po ay magpapaliwanagan lng daw po dahil nakakahiya lng daw po dun sa tumawag sa kanila.Yung tumawag po ay ung isang mayaman na may ari ng waterstation na pinagttrabahuhan nung 32 yr.old na lalaki bilang delivery boy. Pero hindi naman po sa lugar nila nangyari ung insidente. Nung nasaka na po sa police patrol ung kapatid ko kasama ung nanay ko, nakita po nila na ung mayaman na may ari ng waterstation, binigyan ung mga pulis ng dalawang bote ng mamahaling alak at saka po mga softdrinks ung mga pulis.
Nung nahatid na po sa munisipyo ung apatid ko, at pagsunod ko po dun sa kanila ay nkita ko n nga lang po na nakakulong ung kapatid ko dun at nang tinanong ko ung mga pulis ay sinabi nga po n hindi naman daw un nakasara. tama po ba ung ganun na ginawa ng mga pulis..
Pinalabas na lng po cya dun nung nagreklamo ako sa hepe ng pulisya...at ginawan na po agad nila ng papel ung kapatid ko at attempted murder ung
nilagay nila samantalang sa knila naman nagsimula ung gulo. un nga lng po ay ung sa knila ang nasugatan.
Naiiuwi rin naman po nmin ung kapatid ko dahil binigay pa rin po cya ng dswd sa custody ng nanay.
Nang sumunod na araw at dinala na po agad sa piskal ung papel ng kapatid ko pero pinabalik po ng piskal sa munisipyo samin dahil slight physical injury lang naman daw po un at kung tutuusin ay pang
barangay hall lang daw po.
Pero parang gusto pa rin pahabain nung kabilang panig, may laban po ba kami dito sa tingin nyo po..

View user profile

rollie002


Arresto Mayor
my brother who is 17 yrs old- papasok to sa exempting circumstances, meaning if your brother acted without discernment, he is exempted from criminal liability. kung yung kapatid ay alam ang tama at mali, he is liable.

ginising pa po sa suntok nung 32 yr.old na lalaki hangang sa nagaway na at dinikdik ung kapatid ko sa pader at nung umuwi po sa bahay nila ung lalaki kumuha ng pamalo na sulo at pinagpapalo ung kapatid ko. Sinasangga nmn po ng kapatid ko ng kamay nya hanggang sa pinukol po ung kapatid ko nung sulo at nung nahawakan ng kapatid ko ung sulo,pinalo po nya dun sa lalaki so ung lalaki nagtamo po ng sugat sa ulo.-
kung hindi man pumasok sa mga nasabi sa itaas, use the justifying circumstances. in this case, the act of your brother will be justified as self-defense. there are 3 requisites na kailangan, 1st may unlawful aggression, 2nd yung ginamit ba na pangdepensa eh reasonable, 3. wala o hindi sapat ang provocation. base sa kwento mo, the act was justified.

sa case naman ng pulis na nagkulong sa kapatid mo, you can file a criminal case

Art. 124. Arbitrary detention. — Any public officer or employee who, without legal grounds, detains a person, shall suffer;
1. The penalty of arresto mayor in its maximum period to prision correccional in its minimum period, if the detention has not exceeded three days



View user profile

kln


Arresto Menor
How about naman po ung sinasabi nung mga pulis na kaya daw po nila inaresto dahil ung crime daw po ay hindi pa daw po nakakalipas ng 24 hrs. Is slight physical injury under that?
Pero nung nagpunta sila sa amin ang sinabi lang po ay isasama nila para papaliwanagan lang. Pero ung nakalagay po dun sa salaysay ng pulis, inaresto nila dahil sa pamukpok ng kapatid ko dun sa lalaki.. which is self defense naman po.

View user profile

rollie002


Arresto Mayor
a police cannot arrest a person without a warrant, the exceptions in warrantless arrest are;
a. When, in his presence, the person to be arrested has committed, is actually committing, or is attempting to commit an offense;
(b) When an offense has in fact just been committed, and he has personal knowledge of facts indicating that the person to be arrested has committed it; and
c.)When the person to be arrested is a prisoner who has escaped from a penal establishment or place where he is serving final judgment or temporarily confined while his case is pending, or has escaped while being transferred from one confinement to another.

kung hindi under dito ang arrest,then the arrest was unlawful, i never heard that it is a valid reason yung sabihin na hindi pa nakakalipas yung 24 hrs.

View user profile

rollie002


Arresto Mayor
Slight physical injuries and maltreatment -
1. when the offender has inflicted physical injuries which shall incapacitate the offended party for labor from one to nine days, or shall require medical attendance during the same period or;

2.the offender has caused physical injuries which do not prevent the offended party from engaging in his habitual work nor require medical assistance.

3.when the offender shall ill-treat another by deed without causing any injury

the complainant can file slight physical injuries but as i have said and based on your facts, papasok yun sa justifying or exempting, most likely,in my opinion the case will be dismissed.

View user profile

glenn_npt


Arresto Menor
Wala bang naka witness nung pangyayari? Is it the first time na makita nung kapatid mo itong tao na Ito? Pina medical mo din ba tong kapatid mo? If all you're statements are true, I think kahit mas nasaktan yung kabila eh nag file na rin kayo ng kaso Laban sa kanya. Wala ba kayo mahahanap na butas dun sa sumuntok sa kapatid mo? If that person is punching anybody without any reason at all, especially a sleeping person. Then it is possible that this is not the first time na ginawa Nya yun. I think you should do a background check on that person. Tungkol naman dun sa mayaman na tumutulong kamo dun sa kalaban nyo wag mo na cya intindihin dahil Kung NASA tama ka. Wala cya magagawa dun. Always remember, no one is above the law. Kung NASA tama ka ipaglaban mo. After all water station Lang nag business nun, I doubt Kung kaya Nya suportahan ng abogado yun kalaban nyo. Kaltukan ko pa un eh. Joke!

View user profile

kln


Arresto Menor
In continuation to this issue po, last week pinatawag po ng dswd ung kapatid ko and ung mother ko, dinala sila sa piskal kasama ung kabilang panig. Tinatanong ng piskal kung hindi daw ba magpapaareglo ung kabilang panig at ang sabi po nung kabilang panig, gusto dw nila bayaran n lng ung nagasta which is 13 thousand. Eh wala nmn po kming perang ganun at saka hindi naman po ganung kagrabe ung naging sugat nung kabilang panig para sa 13 thousand. Kung itutuloy n lng po at ilalaban namin ung kaso na to, what po ba ang next na dapat namin gawin.

View user profile

attyLLL


moderator
start compiling your evidence, and affidavits of you and your witnesses.


_________________
[i] Visit our FB Page: BPO Employee Legal Advice
Warning and Disclaimer: I am not your lawyer; and you are not my client. With the limitations of an  Internet forum, a thorough review of your concern is not possible. View my comments at YOUR OWN RISK. It is best to actually retain a lawyer for your individual concerns.
View user profile

simpleporfavor


Arresto Menor
a police cannot arrest a person without a warrant, the exceptions in warrantless arrest are;
(b) When an offense has in fact just been committed, and he has personal knowledge of facts indicating that the person to be arrested has committed it; and

>>>good evening,for clarifications po sana above excemptions in arresting a person without a warrant..under item B po mgfall ung incident that defendant from barangay hall they have been brought in police station, then once nakuha na po ung statement dinala cla sa cityhall sa head police station para humarap sa imbestigador then was put in detention cell.?
ask ko din po, from the time arrested, ilang oras po ba bago pwde ipasok sa detention cell ang taong naakusahan? thanks

View user profile

kln


Arresto Menor
In addition to this issue po, ung DSWD head po sa lugar namin gusto po ay makipag areglo na lng po ung nanay ko dun sa nakalaban ng kapatid ko.. 13 thousand po ung hinihingi samin. Wala nman po kming gnung pera dahil mahirap lng po kami. At sabi pa daw po nung dswd ay sa susunod daw po ay wala na daw pong magiging abogado from PAO ung kapatid ko. At isa pa po ay slight physical injury lng po un, para hingan po nila kami ng malaking halaga. Ano po ba ang maiipapayo nyo sa amin, salamat po.

View user profile

attyLLL


moderator
my advice is the same. start preparing your defense.


_________________
[i] Visit our FB Page: BPO Employee Legal Advice
Warning and Disclaimer: I am not your lawyer; and you are not my client. With the limitations of an  Internet forum, a thorough review of your concern is not possible. View my comments at YOUR OWN RISK. It is best to actually retain a lawyer for your individual concerns.
View user profile

Sponsored content


View previous topic View next topic Back to top  Message [Page 1 of 1]

Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum